As parents, we naturally want to protect our children from distress. We want to prevent the tears, solve the friendship conflict, step in when a task feels too hard, and make sure they do not feel disappointed. I have heard from many parents who feel enormous pressure to do everything “right” to anticipate every need, remove every obstacle, and make sure their child is always okay.
However, children also need opportunities to practise being not okay for a moment and to discover that they can move through frustration, disappointment, and challenge with support.
A longitudinal study by Perry and colleagues followed 422 children from toddlerhood to age 10. The researchers explored whether overcontrolling parenting in toddlerhood was associated with children’s later ability to regulate emotions and behaviour, and with their social, emotional, and academic adjustment in preadolescence.
What do researchers mean by “overcontrolling”?
In this study, overcontrol was not simply being involved, setting limits, or helping a young child. It referred to parenting behaviours such as being overly strict or demanding for the situation, repeatedly directing the child, physically taking over, or closely controlling an activity rather than allowing the child space to participate independently.
The concern is that when adults consistently intervene before a child has had a chance to try, struggle, or recover, the child may have fewer opportunities to practise important skills. These include managing big feelings, waiting, shifting strategies, tolerating frustration, and controlling an impulse.
The key findings
The researchers observed mother–child interactions when children were age 2, assessed children’s emotion regulation and inhibitory control at age 5, and gathered child and teacher reports of adjustment at age 10.
They found that higher observed maternal overcontrol at age 2 was associated with lower emotion regulation and inhibitory control at age 5. In other words, children whose mothers were more likely to take charge of interactions had more difficulty managing distress and controlling behavioural impulses several years later.
Those self-regulatory skills mattered. At age 10, stronger emotion regulation at age 5 was associated with fewer child-reported emotional and school problems, along with stronger teacher-reported social skills and academic productivity. Stronger inhibitory control was associated with fewer emotional and school problems and better academic productivity.
The goal is to support or scaffold, not stepping back completely
This research is not asking parents to let children handle everything alone or to ignore genuine distress. Children develop self-regulation through co-regulation: a caring adult stays emotionally available, helps make sense of feelings, and offers enough guidance to help the child try again.
The practical question is not, “Should I help?” It is: “What is the smallest amount of help my child needs to take the next step themselves?”. This is scaffolding.
You might try saying: “This is frustrating. I am here. What could you try first?” That creates a powerful balance: your child feels supported, while also getting to practise the skills that build confidence, resilience, and independence.
A reflection for parents
Before you step in to solve the next problem, pause and ask yourself:
Is my child truly unable to manage this moment or is this an uncomfortable but safe opportunity for them to practise?
You do not have to choose between being a supportive parent and encouraging independence. Often, the most supportive response is to stay close, acknowledge the hard feeling, and give your child enough space to take the next step themselves. Reflect, too, on what makes it difficult to watch your child struggle. Is it their distress that feels unbearable or what their distress brings up in you? There is no shame in finding this hard. Parenting asks us to grow alongside our children.
For a thoughtful, practical exploration of this topic, I recommend The Gift of Failure by Jessica Lahey. It offers helpful ways to think about building children’s independence, responsibility, motivation, and capacity to learn from mistakes without withdrawing the support and connection they need. I had the lovely opportunity of interviewing Jessica on my podcast, The Reflective Parenting Podcast a few years ago. You can listen here!
(Join our book club if you enjoy learning and reflecting about parenting through books).
Join our 8-week cohort (Start October 20th, 2026)
If you find yourself unsure of how to stay emotionally present when your child is upset, frustrated, or struggling, you are not alone. The Emotionally Aware Parent is a course and cohort was created to help parents better understand their own emotional patterns, support their child’s emotional development, and respond with more confidence during difficult moments. Our next 8-week cohort launches October 20, with an introductory price of $399 (regularly $499).

